Holiday Ordering

Thanksgiving orders for pickup Tuesday November 26th or Wednesday November 27th must be placed and paid by Friday November 22nd. Christmas orders for pickup December 20th - 24th must be placed and paid by December 16th. Please email or call and let us know what kind of pie you would like. If you have a favorite pie flavor not mentioned below we still may be able to make it for you depending on fruit availability. Pies can be picked up at Betty Restaurant or delivery can be arranged. 

Whole Pies

Choose either Classic 9" round pie (serves 6-8) $25 or Slab pie (9" x 13" serves 8 - 12) $40

Thanksgiving and Christmas flavors

Pumpkin pie

Classic butter crust, fresh roasted Carpinito Brothers pumpkin in a classic spiced custard

Pear Huckleberry

Cornmeal rosemary crust, fresh pears and wild huckleberries

Caramel Apple Sesame

Classic butter crust, fresh apples tossed in cinnamon and caramel with a sesame streusel top.

Maple Pecan

Classic butter crust, fresh chopped pecans, with maple syrup and browned butter filling. (chocolate added upon request)


Honey graham pie crust, bittersweet chocolate ganache, vanilla marshmallow fluff

Devil's Pie

Peanut butter chess pie with bittersweet chocolate ganache, classic butter pie crust and salted peanuts